 |
| The cost of climate change. Interactive version here. |
Several times recently, I've read or had it put to me that we don't know if global warming is going to be harmful or costly, and, specifically,
that some economists think it may produce a net benefit.
To investigate this claim, I went to Google Scholar with the search terms "cost climate change." I ignored any article that wasn't about the cost of climate change, and also ignored any article not either written by a trained economist or published in their literature. I took only articles from 2009 onwards, picking up where
this interesting study left off (Tol looks at 211 estimates of the cost of climate change, finding eight negative estimates (out of 211) from the work of just three authors, including Tol himself. He concludes -- and, as background, he is unquestionably the most respected and accomplished of the "skeptical" economists -- "
Firstly, greenhouse gas emission reduction today is
justified. Even the most conservative assumption lead to positive estimates of the social
cost of carbon (cf. Table 1) and the Pigou tax is thus greater than zero.")
So onwards towards the present:
1. I quickly found out Martin L. Weitzman
is not sanguine:
It is difficult to imagine what +10C–20°C might
mean for life on Earth, but such high temperatures have not
been seen for hundreds of millions of years and such a rate
of change over a few centuries would be unprecedented
even on a timescale of billions of years. Global average
warming of 10°C–20°C masks tremendous local and seasonal variation, which can be expected to produce temperature increases greater than this at particular times in particular places. Because these hypothetical temperature
changes would be geologically instantaneous, they would effectively destroy planet Earth as we know it. At a mini-
mum such temperatures would trigger mass species extinctions and biosphere ecosystem disintegration matching or
exceeding the immense planetary die-offs associated in Earth’s history with a handful of previous geoenvironmental
mega-catastrophes. There exist some truly terrifying consequences of mean temperature increases +10°C–20°C, such
as disintegration of Greenland’s and at least the western part of the Antarctic’s ice sheets with dramatic raising of sea
level by perhaps thirty meters or so, critically important changes in ocean heat transport systems associated with
thermohaline circulations, complete disruption of weather, moisture and precipitation patterns at every planetary scale,
highly consequential geographic changes in freshwater availability, and regional desertification.
All of the above-mentioned horrifying examples of climate-
change mega-disasters are incontrovertibly possible on a
timescale of centuries.
Geez, Martin, thanks for the pep talk.
2. Burniaux et al, writing for the OCED, are less terrified but
equally convinced:
The benefits of mitigation policies are difficult to quantify and fully monetise. Nevertheless,
OECD analysis finds that when non-market impacts and risks of inaction are factored in,
ambitious mitigation action is found to be economically rational – i.e. to result in net benefits –
at the global level. This is the case even though the analysis does not factor in the co-benefits
from mitigation action (e.g. in terms of human health, energy security or biodiversity), which
previous OECD analysis estimated to be large (Burniaux et al. 2008).
3. I found Richard Tol had done
another meta-analysis:
I review the literature on the economic impacts of climate change, an
externality that is unprecedentedly large, complex, and uncertain. Only
14 estimates of the total damage cost of climate change have been
published, a research effort that is in sharp contrast to the urgency of
the public debate and the proposed expenditure on greenhouse gas
emission reduction. These estimates show that climate change initially
improves economic welfare. However, these benefits are sunk. Impacts
would be predominantly negative later in the century. Global average
impacts would be comparable to the welfare loss of a few percent of
income, but substantially higher in poor countries. Still, the impact of
climate change over a century is comparable to economic growth over a
few years. There are over 200 estimates of the marginal damage cost of
carbon dioxide emissions. The uncertainty about the social cost of
carbon is large and right-skewed. For a standard discount rate, the
expected value is $50/tC, which is much lower than the price of carbon
in the European Union but much higher than the price of carbon
elsewhere. Current estimates of the damage costs of climate change are
incomplete, with positive and negative biases. Most important among the
missing impacts are the indirect effects of climate change on economic
development; large-scale biodiversity loss; low-probability, high-impact
scenarios; the impact of climate change on violent conflict; and the
impacts of climate change beyond 2100. From a welfare perspective, the
impact of climate change is problematic because population is
endogenous, and because policy analyses should separate impatience, risk
aversion, and inequity aversion between and within countries.
4. Bollen et al revisit a longtime hobbyhorse of IT, the additional benefits to human health and welfare of cutting fossil fuel burning, a major cause of asthma, lung cancer and other respiratory diseases. They think the air pollution benefits may be the larger benefit! But, again,
there's no suggestion than global warming isn't a significantly costly event:
We attempt to cover at least part of the existing
gap in the literature by assessing how costs and benefits of
technologies and strategies that jointly tackle these two environmental
problems can best be balanced. By using specific technological options
that cut down local air pollution, e.g. related to particulate
emissions, one may concurrently reduce CO2 emissions and thus
contribute to diminishing global climate change. Inversely, some of the
long-term climate change strategies simultaneously improve the quality
of air in the short run. We have extended the well-established MERGE
model by including emissions of particulate matter, and show that
integrated environmental policies generate net global welfare benefits.
We also demonstrate that the discounted benefits of local air pollution
reduction significantly outweigh those of global climate change
mitigation, at least by a factor of 2, but in most cases of our
sensitivity analysis much more. Still, we do not argue to only restrict
energy policy today to what should be our first priority, local air
pollution control, and wait with the reduction of greenhouse gas
emissions. Instead, we propose to design policies that simultaneously
address these issues, as their combination creates an additional climate
change bonus. As such, climate change mitigation proves an ancillary
benefit of air pollution reduction, rather than the other way around.
5. Hill et al, who are primarily concerned with
analyzing the utility of biofuels, cleverly use estimates of the cost of CCS (carbon capture and storage) to set an upper limit on carbon costs:
We generate a monetary cost for GHG emissions based on independent
estimates of carbon mitigation costs, carbon market prices,
and the social cost of carbon. Carbon mitigation
(capture and storage) costs for an integrated gasification
combined-cycle
electricity generating plant are $92–$147 Mg−1 C (18); we use the midpoint of this range, $120 Mg−1 C. This estimate is in the range of recent prices on the European carbon market [€23–28 Mg−1 CO2, or U.S. $133–$162 Mg−1 C at an exchange rate of $1.58 €−1 in July 2008, and €18–23 Mg−1 CO2, or U.S. $88–$112 Mg−1 C at an exchange rate of $1.33 €−1 in October 2008] (molecular weight ratio of CO2:C
= 44:12). It is also within the range of estimates for the “social cost
of carbon,” which represents the expected future
damages from enhanced climate change (e.g., damages
from sea level rise, increased storm intensity, and crop losses from
more
intensive drought). The mean estimate of the social
cost of carbon from peer-reviewed studies was $43 Mg−1 C (19), although there was large variation in the estimates from below $0 to >$300 Mg−1
C. The large variation in estimates occurs largely because of
disagreement on how to weigh future costs and benefits relative
to the present (“discounting”) and how to weigh costs
and benefits accruing to poor and rich countries (“equity weights”).
In addition, there are large uncertainties about
climate forcing impacts and future human adaptability.
6. Anthoff, Hepburn, and Tol (him again!) find that equity-weighting increases the estimated damages of climate change. What is equity weighting? I have no idea (the downside of wading through the economists' literature). My usual approach is useless -- there's no Wikipedia page. At any rate, they use a damages estimate that is positive, based on Tol's earlier work.
Climate change will give rise to different impacts in different
countries, and different countries have different levels of development.
Equity-weighted estimates of the (marginal) impact of greenhouse gas
emissions reflect these differences. This paper analyses the impact of
equity weighting on the marginal damage cost of carbon dioxide
emissions, and reaches four main conclusions. First, equity-weighted
estimates are substantially higher than estimates without
equity-weights; equity-weights may even change the sign of the social
cost estimates. Second, estimates differ by two orders of magnitude
depending on the region to which the equity weights are
normalised. Third, equity-weighted estimates are sensitive to the
resolution of the impact estimates. Depending on the assumed
intra-regional income distribution, estimates may be more than twice as
high if national rather than regional impacts are aggregated. Fourth,
variations in the assumed inequality aversion have different impacts in
different scenarios, not only because different scenarios have different
emissions and hence warming, but also because different scenarios have
different income differences, different growth rates, and different
vulnerabilities.
7. Ackerman et al feel existing estimates of the economic damages of climate change
systematically underestimate the problem:
The integrated assessment models (IAMs) that economists use to analyze
the expected costs and benefits of climate policies
frequently suggest that the “optimal” policy is to go slowly
and to do relatively little in the near term to reduce greenhouse
gas emissions. We trace this finding to the contestable
assumptions and limitations of IAMs. . . . A better
approach to climate policy, drawing on recent research on the
economics of uncertainty, would reframe the problem as buying
insurance against catastrophic, low-probability events. Policy
decisions should be based on a judgment concerning the maximum
tolerable increase in temperature and/or carbon dioxide levels
given the state of scientific understanding. The appropriate
role for economists would then be to determine the least-cost
global strategy to achieve that target. While this remains a
demanding and complex problem, it is far more tractable and
epistemically
defensible than the cost-benefit comparisons attempted by most
IAMs.
8. Anthoff and Tol are back, "
Discounting for Climate Change":
. . . However, if we
probabilistically constrain the parameters to values that are implied
by observed behaviour, we find that the expected social cost
of carbon, corrected for uncertainty and inequity, is approximate 60 US
dollar per metric tonne of carbon (or roughly $17 per tonne of CO2)
under the assumption that catastrophic risk is zero.
. . . the problem with that being that catastrophic risk isn't zero. In any case, again the cost is positive.
9.Heltberg et al don't give us a number, but they don't give any hint they think climate change will be of net benefit in "
Addressing human vulnerability to climate change: Toward a ‘no-regrets’ approach":
Recent evidence and predictions indicate that climate changes are accelerating and will
lead to wide-ranging shifts in climate variables. There will be changes in the mean and variance
of rainfall and temperature, extreme weather events, food and agriculture production and prices,
water availability and access, nutrition and health status. The most adverse impacts are predicted
in the developing world because of geographic exposure, reliance on climate sensitive sectors,
low incomes, and weak adaptive capacity. Socio-economic impacts, though generally not well-
understood, are likely to be profound and will impact humans through a variety of direct and
indirect pathways (IPCC, 2007; Cline, 2007; Stern, 2007). The indirect risks are often hard to
predict (they are the consequences of consequences) but could have the worst impacts.
10. Jamet and Corfee-Morlot (love those French names) round out our top ten with a nice review: "
Assessing the Impacts of Climate Change":
On the whole, estimates of the global impact of climate change have not changed much over the
last 10 years according to the IPCC (Figure 3). However, the Stern review estimates are much larger than
in other studies. As already mentioned, this is mainly due to a low discount rate, and to a lesser extent to
new information regarding the impacts (Nordhaus, 2007a; Dasgupta, 2007). Nevertheless, use of a low
discount rate may involuntarily yield more plausible estimates than those in the rest of the literature
(Weitzman, 2007). This is in part because there are large uncertainties on the impacts of climate change,
which are explained in more detail in the following section.
So what have we learned from this exercise? For my part I am reminded again that it is much easier to be a liar than to defend the truth. It's easy for a denier to causally toss off the assertion that some economists think climate change will be of net benefit. Maybe they are thinking of Lomborg (who
supports a carbon tax, and anyhow is
not actually an economist) or Tol (who is also on record supporting a carbon tax.) Maybe they are just repeating something they've heard; maybe they think it sounds plausible and no one is likely to check. But in any case the misinformation is the work of a moment; fact-checking it takes weary hours.
At any rate: economists more or less universally believe that the impact of global warming will be a net negative. They differ as to the magnitude of the damages expected, but for the most part they are in broad agreement with the climate scientists that global warming on a business as usual pathway will be expensive and destructive in the best case and utterly catastrophic at the worst.